| Author |
|
The
RealMonkey Newbie

Joined:
27 June 04 Online Status: Offline Posts: 10
|
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 09:40 | IP Logged |
|
|
Snoopy wrote:
I'm sorry to hear you base your whole
opposition to homeopathy on placebo.
It's so thin, Rolfe. We give remedies and
nothing happens. We keep trying.
Finally something works. Why didn't it
work with the first one? There's less
likely to be a placebo response after the
person has been disappointed repeatedly.
If the sick individual is disposed to
respond favorably to a healer, it would
happen immediately and not after hours have
gone
by. | | |
I
don't think Rolfe or anyone else makes very much of the
placebo effect to explain homeopathy, it seems to me a
rather minor issue. Indeed your argument is a reasonable
one against it having much of a role. I think much more
important are coincidence and misinterpretation.
I
can offer another major explanation as well that is often
overlooked. We all agree that a minority of patients can
suffer unpleasant side effects from real medicines.
Homeopathy is very much a minoirty discipline. Even if
only a small number of patients with side effects go to a
homeopath they will represent a big part of your workload.
For many of them, your advice to cut down or cut out their
real medicines may be genuinely beneficial to them. You will
see a benefit in your patients and this time it is a real
benefit, but you have misconstrued the cause. An awful lot
of the cases we see discussed by homeopaths fit this model
very well and I suspect it is a large part of the
explanation of what goes on in a homeopath's practice.
So I would say, coincidental improvement of cyclical
or self-limiting diseases and removal of conventional
medicines are the bulk of what is seen by homeopaths.
Genuine placebo effect is probably a small part.
Outright lying and misrepresentation does occur and I
have documented cases, as does Rolfe, but what percentage
of the whole these represent I do not know. The people
responsible for the cases I know about get very hot under
the collar about their legitimacy and honesty, it's just
that I know the counter-evidence to those self- righteous
assertions. Within this group I do not not how much is
wilful deception of the public and how much is
self-deception by someone who is so deeply into homeopathy
that they can no longer see what is really happening to
their cases. Rolfe and I know of one practitioner who does
seem to know he is crooked, but there is always the
problem of proof. Whether there are more crooked
homeopaths than real doctors I do not know: the alt med
world seems to attract outright crooks bumping up the
proportion, but there are a lot of conventional doctors so
even a small percentage of bad apples would be a large
number.
In the absence of proper studies of your case
loads, these issues are not possible to resolve, but I
think the absence of real effect from the remedies
themselves is incontrovertible.
|
| Back to Top |
|
| |
doctorleela Silver Member

Joined:
27 Jan. 03 Online Status: Offline Posts: 430
|
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 10:32 | IP Logged |
|
|
Snoopy, Barb and NH - this has and always been a waste of
time and energy. I've not even bothered to read through these
3 pages because its the same old boring stuff.
These people are deliberately violating the forum rules
anyway - just shows their basic lack of intergrity and
scruples. And then they want to point fingers at
others! Why bother with them? |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
The
RealMonkey Newbie

Joined:
27 June 04 Online Status: Offline Posts: 10
|
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 10:51 | IP Logged |
|
| [QUOTE=doctorleela]Snoopy,
Barb and NH - this has and always been a waste of time and
energy. I've not even bothered to read through these 3
pages because its the same old boring stuff.[/ QUOTE]
This thread was started by NH and replied to by NH and
Syed before any of the JREF regulars even knew it was
here.
It is not the same old boring stuff. It is new
stuff. Snoopy is now predicating all of homeopathic
practice on conventional diagnoses and saying that you
cannot act without it. Syed, for one, doesn't agree, which
is accord with homeopathic rules, but then he wants to
treat an acute Addisonian crisis with homeopathy alone.
Snoopy has imputed an accusation that it's all placebo
effect and I have corrected that mistaken view.
Edited by The RealMonkey on
05 July 04 at 10:54 |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
The
RealMonkey Newbie

Joined:
27 June 04 Online Status: Offline Posts: 10
|
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 10:53 | IP Logged |
|
| p.s the main
breach of forum rules recently has been NH's knee-jerk
unhomeopathic prescribing in the thread about calves. Not
forgetting Wim's recommendation of non-classical
combination therapy for cats with hyperthyroidism, which
is also explicitly against the rules for case discussions.
|
| Back to Top |
|
| |
exarch Newbie

Joined:
31 May 04 Online Status: Offline Posts: 11
|
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 11:58 | IP Logged |
|
|
doctorleela wrote:
| These people are
deliberately violating the forum rules anyway -
just shows their basic lack of intergrity
and scruples. And then they want to point
fingers at others! Why bother with
them? | | | I
violated forum rules? Any of us violated forum rules? Kindly
point out which ones?
None of us posted any material which is vulgar, defamatory,
inaccurate, harassing, hateful, threatening, invading of
others privacy, sexually oriented, or violating any
laws. We didn't post any copyrighted material that is not
owned by ourself or the owners of these forums.
We only posted things you really just don't want to hear,
but that's your problem, not ours. We're just calling the
facts as we see them. Your inability to accept this truth is
not a violation of the rules in any way.
But then again...
Quote:
| Although messages posted are not
the responsibility of this forum and we are not
responsible for the content or accuracy of any
of these messages, we reserve the right to
delete any message for any or no reason
whatsoever. | | | ...
censorship is just around the corner, so this
truth, which offends you so much, will be gone soon
anyway.
Edited by exarch on
05 July 04 at 11:59 |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Wim
Pardaan Senior Member


Joined:
21 May 04 Location: Netherlands Online
Status: Online Posts: 509 |
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 12:47 | IP Logged |
|
| Hello
RealMonkey, You make a mistake here, since you refer to the
rules of CASE DISCUSSION, where there are stricter rules
applied ! And for the rest, as long as I can cure many animals
(most of them !) and see the happy faces of people, especially
children, I actually couldn`t care less what you say ! I used
to be a very suspicious detective once, even qualified as a
teacher for the police academy, qualified teacher for
grammar schools, qualified teacher of judo etc. I say this to
show you I`m not particularly a gullible/credulous kind
of person. So I am a paragon, a model, of a true believer
in homeopathy
!
__________________ Wim
Pardaan,qualified classical+clinical homeopath for
people+animals.
|
| Back to Top |
|
| |
The
RealMonkey Newbie

Joined:
27 June 04 Online Status: Offline Posts: 10
|
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 13:22 | IP Logged |
|
|
Wim Pardaan wrote:
Hello RealMonkey, You make a
mistake here, since you refer to the rules
of CASE DISCUSSION, where there are
stricter rules applied
! | | |
A
nice distinction. Well done. So, it's OK to give bad advice
outside that forum.
Wim Pardaan wrote:
And for the rest, as long as I
can cure many animals (most of them
!) | | |
Just
no objective evidence to prove that assertion. Shame. Try
monitoring T4 next time you see a hyperthyroid cat.
Ironically, I first became aware of homeopathy's claims
with respect to animals when I came across a homeopath
lying about the outcome of a hyperthyroid cat. He hadn't
checked its T4 either. |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Naturalhealth Senior Member


Joined:
08 March 04 Location: United Kingdom Online
Status: Offline Posts: 400 |
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 13:27 | IP Logged |
|
| Ok, I am going
to do this publicly so that every single person on this
board can see you reply to this and you can be shamed once
and for all.
Rolfe,
Below is what is in your
signature line at Randiland about Snoopy. WOULD YOU REMOVE
THIS AS IT IS BOTH UNTRUE ABOUT SNOOPY AND IS QUITE
FRANKLY A LIBELOUS STATEMENT ABOUT HER BASED ON YOUR
FICTION!!!!
"To give Rolfe his due, I think this is a
good example to everyone of what can happen if we fail to
get a proper diagnosis and begin treating on symptoms
alone--a big mistake, as shown here." - "Snoopy" on
H'pathy Forums, apparently abjuring the very fundamentals
of homoeopathy after she'd just allowed a
young mother with Addison's disease to die."
We know what the truth is and do not need to be
corrected at all. We SEE this truth on a daily basis in
our practices. Perhaps you should have someone remove
the rod in YOUR OWN EYE SO THAT YOU CAN SEE MORE
CLEARLY!!!
We really are not worried by anything that
you say at all. We will just carry on running our
practices and helping people in the best way that we know
how, HOMEOPATHICALLY.
__________________ Medical
Homeopath MFHom
|
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Naturalhealth Senior Member


Joined:
08 March 04 Location: United Kingdom Online
Status: Offline Posts: 400 |
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 14:31 | IP Logged |
|
| Well, having
just visited Randiland Rolfe is seen as the true coward he
really is. Ha, ha, not surprise there then.
He
posts there but of course is far too cowardly to come and
post the same thing here. Sigh, Sigh.
The bunch of
idiotic morons from Randipathetics just get so boring I
can hardly be bothered to post anymore.
Perhaps
you guys could use some meditation practice to help you
chill out a bit!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
__________________ Medical
Homeopath MFHom
|
| Back to Top |
|
| |
exarch Newbie

Joined:
31 May 04 Online Status: Offline Posts: 11
|
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 15:10 | IP Logged |
|
|
Naturalhealth wrote:
We know what the truth is and do
not need to be corrected at all. We SEE this
truth on a daily basis in our practices.
Perhaps you should have someone remove the
rod in YOUR OWN EYE SO THAT YOU CAN SEE MORE
CLEARLY!!!
We really are not worried by
anything that you say at all. We will just
carry on running our practices and helping
people in the best way that we know how,
HOMEOPATHICALLY. | | |
We know the truth now too NaturalHealth, and that is that
you folks are dangerously incompetent when it comes to
recognising real life threatening diseases.
Your dislike of conventional medicine has so distorted your
way of thinking that you would suggest a woman suffering from
Addison's disease to stop taking her birth-control pill. Most
likely, in true homeopathic fashion, if nothing changes wait a
bit longer to see if the change occurs a couple days later,
when the "evil allopathic toxins" have left the body.
Of course, by then the person is dead and conventional
medicine gets to chalk up another casualty on it's list of
people who died in their ER after being rushed there by their
families. No link with homeopathy whatsoever. Meanwhile,
you can close your case file after not hearing anything again
from this person and assuming her stopping to take her
birthcontrol pill solved the problem which is why she didn't
return.
This one hypothetical case has shown that of three
homeopaths responding, none recognised the very clear signs of
a very lethal disease, and all agreed that it was probably
just side effects from birth-control pills.
You are obviously not real doctors, none of you, but you
make your patients believe you are. If they come to you with
potentially life-threatening afflictions, chances are you
won't even know their life is in danger, and just leaf through
your Materia Medica like you always do until you find a
potion that matches most of the symptoms (and make
sure to take note whether the patient likes sausages or hates
green wallpaper, since that can make the big difference in
choosing the right remedy). Then send them home and wait
until they come back. Or don't.
People's lives are in your hands, and you seem to think
it's no big deal that you don't know the first thing about
medicine. You're very quick to condemn conventional medicine
at any chance you get, but even quicker to depend on it when
you find out you really goofed it up.
This little "oopsie" would get a real doctor a hell of a
malpractice suit. You just seem to think it's funny that
we're outraged by the fact you really dropped the ball here,
and you suggest that you know what you're doing. Well, I
suggest that you don't know what you're
doing, and some laws need to be made as soon as
possible to make sure quacks like you aren't allowed to
endanger any more lives, human or animal, or risk serious
jailtime if you do.
(Edited for clarity)
Edited by exarch on 05 July 04
at 15:27 |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Rolfie Newbie

Joined:
04 July 04 Location: England Online Status:
Offline Posts: 13 |
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 15:22 | IP Logged |
|
|
Naturalhealth wrote:
Well, having just visited
Randiland Rolfe is seen as the true coward he
really is. Ha, ha, not surprise there then.
He posts there but of course is far too
cowardly to come and post the same thing here.
Sigh,
Sigh. | | |
Sorry, Naturalhealth, I can't get to you all at once.
You'll just have to wait your turn. I realise, since
you're currently banned at JREF for violating forum rules,
that time might be hanging a bit heavy on your hands at the
moment - but never mind, another few days and you can post
again. So long as you use your original username of
"Homeoskeptic", that is. See you! 
I'd just remind you once again that this entire thread is
100% your fault. I had no serious intention of posting
that hypothetical case here - it was just for Kumar. But
not only did you take it upon yourself to repost my writing
without permission, you completely forgot (or completely
missed) the clear statements in the original thread that this
was a "trick question". Wow, look what happened. I
hope you're proud of yourself. I certainly owe you
one!
Now, about sig lines. Before we discuss mine, how
about yours? You know, that MFHom that you don't
actually have? I wonder how the Faculty of Homoeopathy
would react to the information that a lay person is claiming
their "exclusive" professional homoeopathic diploma?
My JREF sig line quotes someone called "Snoopy". I
assume that isn't her real name. In fact I know it isn't
her real name. If I'd posted that, maybe you'd have a
point. Or maybe not. But I didn't. In
addition, there is also a link to the actual thread, so that
anyone who can't figure out the blindlingly obvious (evident
from the wording of Snoopy's statement itself) that the
situation was hypothetical, can find out the full truth about
the circumstances.
The sig line stays.
Rolfe.
|
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Rolfie Newbie

Joined:
04 July 04 Location: England Online Status:
Offline Posts: 13 |
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 15:31 | IP Logged |
|
|
Homeopath Syed wrote:
| Lastly for the need of Allopathic
Diagnosis...
NO WE DO NOT NEED ONE TO TREAT OUR
PATIENTS....
We rely on Objective and Subjective symptoms
together or apart.
Anyone homeopath who thinks he needs an
Allopathic Diagnosis to treat a PATIENT.. may
please.. post here
again. | | |
Well, I'm not a homoeopath, but this was actually the whole
point of all this. The symptom list posted was literally
a text-book case of a condition which has an extremely
predictable outcome unless the patient gets the right
treatment with real medicine. Pretty soon. And
that outcome is sudden death (from heart failure, due to high
potassium preventing the normal cardiac muscle
contractions from occurring).
If you try to treat someone with this condition, having no
idea at all what you're dealing with, the patient will
die. End of story. Which would be a pity, since it
usually affects young adults, and with proper treatment
patients can expect to live a normal life.
Now, whether a homoeopath could or would try
knowingly to treat a case of Addison's disease
with homoeopathy alone, well I hope that's an academic
question. It would be unthinkable that anyone who
understood what Addison's disease is and what the consequences
are would deny them the known, reliable, life-saving
treatment. I hope.
Of course, Addison's disease is only an example.
There are other circumstances where a non-medically-qualified
person opposed to the idea of diagnosis would miss a
life-threatening condition with the greatest of ease. Do
you have any sense of responsibility at all, Syed?
Rolfe.
|
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Rolfie Newbie

Joined:
04 July 04 Location: England Online Status:
Offline Posts: 13 |
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 15:39 | IP Logged |
|
|
Snoopy wrote:
| I'm sorry to hear you base your whole
opposition to homeopathy on placebo. It's
so thin, Rolfe. We give remedies and
nothing happens. We keep trying.
Finally something works. Why didn't it
work with the first
one? | | |
Well, what a wonderful description of a bunch of medical
cases doing whatever they were going to do anyway!
Snoopy, never did I say that I based my opposition to
homoeopathy on the elusive placebo effect. Which by the
way is not nearly as regular and predictable as you seem to
think, when you point out that the utter randomness of the
responses you see to your remedies proves that this isn't
placebo. (On the contrary, a lot of what you're seeing,
beyond wishful thinking, is coincidental recovery, and that
has exactly the same irregular appearance as you report for
homoeopathic response.)
The point I wanted to explore when I devised the
hypothetical Addison's case was whether homoeopaths could
recognise a potentially life-threatening presentation when it
was described to them in text-book terms. Obviously
not. Even the (allegedly) medically qualified homeopath
who took it upon herself to start all this seems to have
completely missed it.
I was also interested in whether or not homoeopaths would
concede that in a case like this, reliance on homoeopathy
alone would result in a dead patient. I'm not sure I
have a consensus on this, but I've had some interesting points
of view.
I also achieved, quite unexpectedly, the unambiguous
statement that it is "a big mistake" to treat on symptoms
alone without getting a real or allopathic diagnosis.
That one, I have to say, was a big surprise to me. I'm
still not entirely sure who is going to provide this diagnosis
if the patient does as Snoopy's other writings recommend and
goes to a homoeopath first, but it's nevertheless an
interesting admission. I'll leave the resulting spat to
Snoopy and Syed, and whichever other homoeopaths want to get
involved.
Now, since my real interest is in waiting to see if any
homoeopath in the entire world can come up with any means at
all of reliably distinguishing a potentised remedy from a
chemically identical sham, and the answer to that doesn't seem
likely to appear in this thread, I'll bow out now. Pray
ban me at your leisure.
But do take note that being able to influence the health of
patients differently would be an acceptable form of
demonstrating the above point (sorry, trying desperately to
avoid the word "proving" here!). For example, producing
a case or two of unambiguously-diagnosed Addison's disease
that had demonstrably recovered on homoeopathic medicine
alone. But of course, whatever any of you might assert,
nothing of the sort has ever happened.
Until your allegedly self-evident miracle cures can
actually provide some evidence that they have any
physiological effect on the body whatsoever, then the rest of
the discussion is only about ethics. And I'm usually
quite choosy about the company I keep.
Goodnight.
Rolfe.
Edited for spelling.
Edited by Rolfie on 05 July 04
at 15:47 |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Snoopy Silver Member


Joined: 06 April 03
Online Status: Offline Posts: 2178 |
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 15:53 | IP Logged |
|
|
So, your libelous signature line stays, does it?
we'll see about that! This is no longer about medicine,
Rolfe. we're long past that. You're a liar.
You're disreputable. Do you still think this is about
medicine? It's about you and your cohorts who have no
morals, no ethics and no standards of decency. Whatever
your point of view is, you' ve totally disgraced it.
Snoopy
__________________ Diploma,
Hahnemann Academy of North America |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
exarch Newbie

Joined:
31 May 04 Online Status: Offline Posts: 11
|
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 16:27 | IP Logged |
|
|
Snoopy wrote:
| So, your libelous signature line
stays, does it? we'll see about
that! This is no longer about medicine,
Rolfe. we're long past
that. | | |
Perhaps you are past it, but we haven't even started. We're
still on about homeopaths being unfit to diagnose deadly
diseases, and how people WILL die unless
there is some regulation to prevent you from making the
mistake you just made on this hypothetical case in real
life.
Quote:
| You're a liar. You're
disreputable. Do you still think this is
about medicine? It's about you and your
cohorts who have no morals, no ethics and no
standards of decency. Whatever your point
of view is, you' ve totally disgraced
it. | | |
You're the one making contradictory statements here, so who
is really lying? Further more, there is a link to this thread
in the signature, so unless JanZy decides to play censor again
and deletes this whole thread, people will be able to check
out this thread and read what it's all about. You screwed up
royally, and now you'd prefer it all went away. Well, we're
not going to let you forget it that easily. A real
doctor wouldn't be able to escape the consequences of his
mistakes either.
I'll repeat the core of the argument we're making: it's not
that you really killed someone, but that the possibility of it
happening for real is still there. There's nothing to prevent
you from sending a patient with a life threatening affliction
home with a box of ineffective sugar pills because you don't
know anything about medicine. As long as that doesn't change,
the risk is very real, and the signature is oh so very
appropriate. Conventional medical practitioners are not the
ones without morals, ethics and standards of decency here
...
Edited by exarch on
05 July 04 at 16:28 |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
kppy Groupie

Joined:
20 April 04 Location: United States Online
Status: Offline Posts: 94 |
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 16:51 | IP Logged |
|
|
hey exarch,rolfie and real monkey,
you folks "real" doctors? if so, where do you
practice? what is your specialty? |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Yahweh Newbie


Joined: 05 July 04
Online Status: Offline Posts: 1 |
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 19:05 | IP Logged |
|
|
doctorleela wrote:
Snoopy, Barb and NH - this has
and always been a waste of time and energy. I've
not even bothered to read through these 3 pages
because its the same old boring stuff.
These people are deliberately violating
the forum rules anyway - just shows their basic
lack of intergrity and scruples. And then they
want to point fingers at others! Why bother with
them? | | | So
let me get this straight...
You have not read the
previous 3 pages, yet you know the contents of them and have
identified the skeptics as deliberately violating rules? I
must say your newly developed psychic powers are impressive,
but can you tell me who has violated the rules and which
rules? (Note: Those questions are hypothetical, you dont have
to answer them.) |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Georgianna Groupie


Joined:
16 March 04 Location: United States Online
Status: Offline Posts: 57 |
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 19:23 | IP Logged |
|
|
Okay.....whoa.....hold the
presses! Quote *Rolfie* post on 4 July in the Student's
Corner under *7 week old cows dying* (though I should mention,
no one who knows anything about cows would call a 7 week old a
*cow*)......."As a vet, I
must express my hope that ......". What? As a
VET? No kidding. And your practice is so limited
that you have this kind of time to waste? Not one vet I
know has that kind of spare time. If you indeed are a
vet, though obviously not a busy one, it does very well
explain a great deal. Allopathic vets are very concerned
about patients moving away from practices that they
know have endangered their animals for so long and that
would be cause for your attacking that which threatens your
income.
As a wise person once said,
"follow the money". Homeopathy is less expensive than
allopathy, eliminating multiple, multiple visits and multiple,
multiple vaccinations/drugs and then more visits to *cure* the
diseases caused by the multiple vaccinations/drugs......all
very lucrative to vets and very damaging to pets. Animal
caregivers are turning away from this practice in
droves.
So, where do you practice
veterinary medicine, Rolfie? You're so up front and
honest, I'm sure you'll share that with us. What
homeopathic vets are challenging your income in your
backyard?! Running scared, are you?
__________________ Sometimes
on Earth, you can find something that resembles a little piece
of Heaven. And sometimes on Earth, a little piece of Heaven
can find you.
|
| Back to Top |
|
| |
JanZy Gold Member


Joined: 15 Jan. 03
Online Status: Offline Posts: 392 |
| Posted:
05 July 04 at 19:26 | IP Logged |
|
|
Well...hasn't this become a fine little troll party? The
trolls have received splendid answers to their less than full
hypothetical case which NH so grrrrrraciously brought over
here leaving out even more details (or at least, that is what
has been accused...I don't know...I didn't go into Randi land
to soil my feet and waste my time).
While the replies at the onset did not go into a full case
review and anaylsis and recommendations....the intial
recommendation of stopping the BCP was a correct one.
Pregnancy (which bcp's mimic) can cause Addison-like symptoms
in a woman. Further, there was no evidence given of an Adrenal
Crisis....for which emergency medicine would have to be
recommended. Addisons is a chronic condition, coming on
gradually and waxing and waning over the years. It is
frequently misdiagnosed (by medical professionals). And
even then, when diagnosed...medical professionals will often
just treat that 'disease' and miss the underlying cause...(for
example Tuberculosis ...which does not give to manifestations
of coughing when it is in other areas other than the
lungs.)
Taking "text-book" case examples and
working backwards (while thinking you are working forward) is
a sure way to screw up the appropriate analysis and review of
an entire case and miss essential clues and alternate
diagnosis'. There-in lies one of the fundemental differences
between homoepathy and allopathy....if the case doesn't
perfectly fit the picture that the docs were given in med
school or they failed to fully learn the differential
diagnoses...or even more, in their arrogance...fail to
see...they don't have all the answers (just
as homeopathy doesn't or any other health care system) ...THAT
is the danger. (thank you Syed for your statistics on
the wonders of modern medicine. Hurrah for the "necessary
casualties"...now quick...sweep 'em back under the
rug...so they can continue in their delusions and
say...allopathy/trad.meds are THE SAFEST things on the face of
the earth.)
Party is over kids. The parents are home. 
JanZy
Edited by JanZy on
05 July 04 at 19:28 |
| Back to Top |
|
| | | |