| Author |
|
Naturalhealth Senior Member


Joined:
08 March 04 Location: United Kingdom Online
Status: Offline Posts: 396 |
| Posted:
03 July 04 at 04:55 | IP Logged |
|
| Hi All,
Rolfe thought she would try to be very clever by
posting this case over at Randiland. She said that she
would be tempted to re-register and post it for help and
try some real 'trolling' behaviour. I thought I would do
it for her however.
Happy reading one and all.
All right, let's just repeat this again for Kumar, and
any other passing homoeopaths who have the guts to get
involved.
Let's just give a little more detail to
flesh out this patient. She's a 35 year old woman, married
with an eight-year-old daughter. She is taking the
contraceptive pill but no other medication. She was
generally well until about two months previously when
she began to feel unusually fatigued, and developed
unexplained stomach upsets. On presentation the following
symptom picture was elicited.
* Weakness - extreme
* Fatigue - muscle weakness
* Unintentional weight loss
* Nausea
* Vomiting
* Chronic diarrhea
* Loss of appetite
* Darkening of the skin -
skin color, patchy
* Unnaturally dark color in
some locations * Paleness may
also occur * Mouth lesions on
the inside of a cheek (buccal mucosa) - pigmentation
* Slow, sluggish, lethargic
movement * Changes in the
blood pressure or heart rate
* Salt craving
What
would be the homoeopathic approach to handling such a
case?
(Good grief, I'm tempted to re-register at
H'pathy as a homoeopath seeking help with just such a case
and see what they say. I've never tried real trolling
before, but this one's tempting!)
OK, off you go.
It's as real a situation as any other. Homoeopaths of the
world, how do you treat this patient?
Rolfe.
__________________ Medical
Homeopath MFHom
|
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Homeopath
Syed Senior Member


Joined:
20 April 04 Location: Pakistan Online Status:
Offline Posts: 128 |
| Posted:
03 July 04 at 06:52 | IP Logged |
|
|
NH,
Its the contraceptive pill thats doing this job. Ask her
the name of the drug and let her read out aloud the side
affects. usually not all side affects are listed down in the
medicinal printout and for that we usually need help of the
net.
I would really not think of anyother thing until I rule it
out.
__________________ Homeopath
Dr. F.A.Syed Islamabad, Pakistan |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Snoopy Silver Member


Joined: 06 April 03
Online Status: Online Posts: 2156 |
| Posted:
03 July 04 at 11:40 | IP Logged |
|
|
You're right, Syed, go with what's obvious. The
remedy is, stop the birth control pill!
Snoopy |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Snoopy Silver Member


Joined: 06 April 03
Online Status: Online Posts: 2156 |
| Posted:
03 July 04 at 11:41 | IP Logged |
|
| What is wrong
with these people? |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Naturalhealth Senior Member


Joined:
08 March 04 Location: United Kingdom Online
Status: Offline Posts: 396 |
| Posted:
03 July 04 at 13:39 | IP Logged |
|
| Exactly, which
I why I posted this first before Randiland could get a
look in.
A lot of these new posters are trolls in
disguise and they will stop at nothing now.
__________________ Medical
Homeopath MFHom
|
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Snoopy Silver Member


Joined: 06 April 03
Online Status: Online Posts: 2156 |
| Posted:
03 July 04 at 21:59 | IP Logged |
|
| Thanks for the
heads-up! |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Homeopath
Syed Senior Member


Joined:
20 April 04 Location: Pakistan Online Status:
Offline Posts: 128 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 00:29 | IP Logged |
|
| Thanks
Snoopy
__________________ Homeopath
Dr. F.A.Syed Islamabad, Pakistan |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Rolfie Newbie

Joined:
04 July 04 Location: England Online Status:
Offline Posts: 9 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 14:05 | IP Logged |
|
|
Hi, H'pathy, this is Rolfe. Really, this time.
Naturalhealth kindly posted my challenge case for me,
without telling you the catch, or providing the link where you
might have read about the catch for yourselves. So
here's the explanation.
The bulleted list of presenting signs was taken directly
from a medical education page on the Internet describing
Addison's disease. http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/ency/article/000378.htm
Further on in the page the seriousness of the condition is
elaborated on: "Adrenal crisis is an extreme manifestation of
symptoms of adrenal insufficiency precipiated by physical
stress. Intravenous or intramuscular injection of
hydrocortisone must be given immediately to sustain life. ....
Never skip doses of medication for this condition, as
life-threatening reactions may occur." Nevertheless,
"With adequate replacement therapy, most people with Addison's
disease are able to lead normal lives."
Congratulations, Syed and Snoopy, your patient suddenly
collapsed and died the day after you told her just to come off
the pill and not to do anything else. And the
eight-year-old daughter is left without a mother. I hope
you're proud of yourselves.
The point of the case, obviously, was to see if homoeopaths
were really capable of recognising a life-threatening
presentation which urgently needed real medicine, and send the
patient immediately to someone who is qualified to prescribe
that real medicine. You lived right down to my lowest
expectations.
And by the way, have you thought at all about
"Naturalhealth", who used to have a sig with a couple of
lay-person homoeopathic diplomas listed, but has more recently
started claiming to be a real qualified doctor, with a diploma
only available to qualified doctors? I think accepting
that she's lying is more charitable than imagining that a real
doctor could so totally miss the significance of a list of
classic symptoms of a life-threatening disease copied straight
from a text-book. Do you approve of people on your site
claiming qualifications they don't have, in their sig lines no
less?
Oh, I just noticed your rule 5. "We would also
appreciate, if all members can add their
qualification/Occupation and/or real name to their signatures.
This is not compulsory but will help to create a more
professional atmosphere in the long run." What do you
think about someone adding a qualification she doesn't
actually have?
Love and kisses,
Rolfe.
PS. Don't worry about deleting this thread, it's
already copied to my hard drive.
Edited for spelling. What is it with you
guys? Why am I not banned already? It's been close
on two hours!
Edited by
Rolfie on 04 July 04 at 16:00 |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Snoopy Silver Member


Joined: 06 April 03
Online Status: Online Posts: 2156 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 16:04 | IP Logged |
|
|
Schmendrick,
We do not do diagnosing;
our clients come to us with a medical diagnosis and if they
don't have one, we insist that they get one. We cannot
do homeopathy without a diagnosis, so there would have been no
mistake no deaths because in a real life situation and
not a game played on a bulletin board by people with an
inexplicable amount of free time, we would have known that
they had Addison's disease.
In fact, reading over
your symptoms, if someone had called me and said, "I have
weight loss, vomiting, diarrhea, weakness..." I'd have
thought, "Oh my God! This is not good! Do you know
what's causing this, because if not, I think you should
get a diagnosis right away!" You'd have to say
this! I mean, here, on a BB, it's a game, but no one in
real life would say, "Oh yes, why, let me just treat this
thing that frankly sounds like it could be cancer!" So,
this was just another silly parlor game of yours, a trap you
tried to set so that you could say, "Ha-ha! You people
are stupid!" Well, let me tell you, Dr. Bhatia would
have known; so, I really don't know what this says or
doesn't say about homeopathy and it's ability to treat a
case of Addison's disease.
Snoopy
Edited by Snoopy on 04 July 04
at 16:10 |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Georgianna Groupie


Joined:
16 March 04 Location: United States Online
Status: Offline Posts: 55 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 16:17 | IP Logged |
|
|
Do you people have absolutely no
real lives at all? Is this the best thing you have to do
with your time? Get a life. Or have you tried and
can't?
__________________ Sometimes
on Earth, you can find something that resembles a little piece
of Heaven. And sometimes on Earth, a little piece of Heaven
can find you.
|
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Rolfie Newbie

Joined:
04 July 04 Location: England Online Status:
Offline Posts: 9 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 16:17 | IP Logged |
|
|
Well now, isn't that an interesting U-turn, after the whole
thing has been spelled out!
Too late, Snoopy, we all saw your genuine reactions, not
even reconsidered until I drew you a picture.
You talk a good talk about getting a diagnosis, but how
often do you really take one look at a patient and
send them to a doctor? Ever even cross your mind if
there isn't an obvious pumping artery?
Oh, and can we take this as an admission that you agree,
homoeopathy can't treat this disease and shouldn't try?
How about some warnings for people like Syed (and you) who
can't recognise it when a text-book case is staring them in
the face?
Rolfe. |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Snoopy Silver Member


Joined: 06 April 03
Online Status: Online Posts: 2156 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 16:29 | IP Logged |
|
|
Even so, I should still
point out, that it's possible to stop the immediate suffering
with homeopathy while still insisting that the person needs to
get a diagnosis. For example, it's possible to give a
remedy for diarrhea or vomiting, thereby enabling the person
to recover sufficiently to get to the doctor or
emergency room and do what is necessary.
Snoopy |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Rolfie Newbie

Joined:
04 July 04 Location: England Online Status:
Offline Posts: 9 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 16:30 | IP Logged |
|
|
Ah well, I'm going to bed. On the assumption that
I'll be banned (or at least, "Rolfie" will be banned ) by the time I get up, bye-bye.
I'd like to say it's being nice knowing you.
Unfortunately it wouldn't be true, and in spite of undoubtedly
being labelled a troll, I've never lied on this forum yet.
By the way, Georgina, I've got a perfectly satisfactory
life, thanks for asking. Except for the fact that I've
come across some perfectly sickening cases of animal suffering
and death caused by the unwillingness of all concerned to
give up with the magic sugar pills and apply some real
medicine. Which I imagine you'd be hollering for too if
you were really ill. If you go down with Addison's, be
sure not to go to a homoeopath, now.
Au revoir.
Rolfe.
Edited to add: Oh, sure, Snoopy.
Fluids are a good idea for an Addisonian crisis. But
rather more than you're in the habit of giving. Support
to get to the emergency room! You had no idea that it
might possibly be an emergency until I told you! Just
pray that none of you ever has a presentation like this in
real life.
Edited by Rolfie on
04 July 04 at 16:36 |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Snoopy Silver Member


Joined: 06 April 03
Online Status: Online Posts: 2156 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 16:32 | IP Logged |
|
|
I see we were posting at
the same time. I didn't see your post or
Georgie's. Look Rolfie, you set a trap and we fell into
it. As I said, in real life, people come to us with
a diagnosis. Now, if your question is, can homeopathy
treat Addison's disease, the answer is
yes.
Snoopy
__________________ Diploma,
Hahnemann Academy of North America |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Rolfie Newbie

Joined:
04 July 04 Location: England Online Status:
Offline Posts: 9 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 16:40 | IP Logged |
|
|
Oh wow.
You can treat Addison's disease. What, you mean
alone, without assistance from "allopathic" things like
hydrocortisone and fludrocortisone? Do tell! That
one ought to turn the entire field of endocrinology upside
down if you could substantiate it.
Not holding my breath though.
And so patients come to you with a diagnosis, do
they? This is you who wrote all that about how "What
Hahnemann is trying to say here is, see a homeopath
first." (http://www.hpathy.com/papersnew/choose_homeopathy.asp)
(Yes, I saw the bit about how it's still handy to have an
"allopathic" diagnosis, but you don't seem to follow that
particular bit of backside-covering very often in practice, as
far as I can see.)
And please note, I set you no trap. I posted a
hypothetical challenge on the JREF forum, where we were trying
to get Kumar to talk some sense about tissue remedies.
The original context had all the "traps" clearly flagged up,
so you couldn't have fallen into them.
Naturalhealth simply didn't notice, and posted the basic
case here, without even asking permission, by the way.
So, don't blame me, sweetie.
Rolfe.
Edited by Rolfie on
04 July 04 at 16:50 |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Snoopy Silver Member


Joined: 06 April 03
Online Status: Online Posts: 2156 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 16:48 | IP Logged |
|
|
To give Rolfe his due, I
think this is a good example to everyone of what can happen if
we fail to get a proper diagnosis and begin treating on
symptoms alone--a big mistake, as shown
here.
Snoopy
__________________ Diploma,
Hahnemann Academy of North America |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Snoopy Silver Member


Joined: 06 April 03
Online Status: Online Posts: 2156 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 16:55 | IP Logged |
|
|
Rolfe,
You and I keep posting
at the same time, i thought you had gone to bed? Listen,
do you really want to know if homeopathy can treat Addison's
disease? Then why don't you ask, I'm sure Dr. Bhatia has
cases. I don't understand you people. Aren't you
aware that there are homeopathic hospitals? Are you
interested in homeopathy or jousting?
Snoopy
Edited by Snoopy on 04 July 04
at 16:56 |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Rolfie Newbie

Joined:
04 July 04 Location: England Online Status:
Offline Posts: 9 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 17:00 | IP Logged |
|
|
Snoopy wrote:
|
To give
Rolfe his due, I think this is a good example to
everyone of what can happen if we fail to get a
proper diagnosis and begin treating on symptoms
alone--a big mistake, as shown
here.
| | |
OK, Snoopy, that's very sensible.
Now, isn't it just a pity that this flatly contradicts the
very first page or so of the Organon?
The idea that patients can be optimally managed by real
medicine, but then you can just come in and provide some sort
of little "complementary" extra on top is certainly a
relatively safe way of practising your "art". However,
how does that square with the many homoeopaths who declare
absolutely that allopathic medicine simply prevents
homoeopathy from achieving a cure, and (from some people) is
nothing but poison?
Even you, in that article I linked to above, stated, "By
the time they get here, they've already been poisoned,
mutilated, and relieved of their life savings. Nonetheless,
they believe they've taken the right steps in seeing the
"real" doctors first. If only they knew that the modern
medical paradigm is built on a faulty premise!"
Somehow, that doesn't entirely square with the line you're
coming out with now. (Please forgive me, Snoopy, If I'm
mistaken about you being Elaine Lewis. Nevertheless, the
quoted text is still featured on this forum.)
It's a simple medical fact that a patient with Addison's
disease will die without proper treatment. Death can
often occur suddenly without anyone being really aware of how
serious the problem is.
If homoeopathy can prevent this without use of real
medicine, I really think there are a few interesting papers
missing from the literature. On the other hand, if the
real medicine saves the patient and the homoeopathy just
claims to add a little unspecified something on top, whose
being most profligate with the life savings?
Rolfe.
Edited to add quote, because simultaneous posting was
spoiling the sense of this.
Edited by Rolfie on 04 July 04
at 17:36 |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Rolfie Newbie

Joined:
04 July 04 Location: England Online Status:
Offline Posts: 9 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 17:01 | IP Logged |
|
|
Well, I was going to bed on the assumption that JanZy would
soon ban me as a troll and delete this thread, as is
her usual practice. It never seriously occurred to me
that people so deep in a hole would go on digging.
By the way, Snoopy, while I'm still alive, I always meant
to ask. What is it with the supersized brightly-coloured
text? It dazzles me.
Rolfe.
Edited for spelling. I can't believe I'm not
banned yet!
Edited by
Rolfie on 04 July 04 at 17:05 |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
exarch Newbie

Joined:
31 May 04 Online Status: Online Posts: 3 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 17:11 | IP Logged |
|
|
Snoopy wrote:
|
Listen, do
you really want to know if homeopathy can treat
Addison's disease? Then why don't you ask,
I'm sure Dr. Bhatia has cases. I don't
understand you people. Aren't you aware
that there are homeopathic hospitals? Are
you interested in homeopathy or
jousting? | | |
Wow, you THINK homeopathy can cure
Addison's disease. Of course, you don't know for sure, since
you have no knowledge of cases where that really happened
(this is because they don't exist). You are quite convinced Dr
Bhatia has cases of people being cured of Addison's
without help from conventional medicine (I'm quite
convinced he doesn't), and somehow you all get really upset if
we call homeopathy a belief system (which you clearly show it
to be). Objective evidence and good science are clearly wasted
on you Snoopy, you will believe it works because it must
according to your belief system, even if it kills your
patients. And yes, Addison's WILL kill your
patients if you give them nothing but shaken water, although
some are going to last a little longer than others.
Edited to add: I see Rolfe already explained to you
that patients WILL die without proper medical
care.
Edited by exarch
on 04 July 04 at 17:15 |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Rolfie Newbie

Joined:
04 July 04 Location: England Online Status:
Offline Posts: 9 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 17:20 | IP Logged |
|
|
Snoopy wrote:
|
Listen, do
you really want to know if homeopathy can treat
Addison's disease? Then why don't you ask,
I'm sure Dr. Bhatia has cases. I don't
understand you people. Aren't you aware
that there are homeopathic hospitals? Are
you interested in homeopathy or
jousting? | | |
Sorry, Snoopy, I just noticed that part.
I'm interested in finding out if a case of a potentially
life-threatening disease can be recognised as such by a
homoeopath, in time for the patient to be saved.
I'm well aware of homoeopathic "hospitals" (most of which
don't even have in-patient facilities in this country).
I'm not really interested in discussing whether or not
hoemoeopathic treatment can provide any sort of "extra" over
and above necessary real medical treatment, at least not in
this thread. Can homoeopathy cope alone with
genuinely life-threatening conditions which are recognised to
require real medicine? Or if not (and all the evidence
I've ever seen is on the "not" side), can homoeopaths be
trusted to recognise such cases and refer as necessary?
That was the point of the original hypothetical "case", which
I must point out once more was not posted here by me.
Now, taking for the moment your acceptance of the
"allopathic" diagnosis of Addison's disease, I would be
extremely interested to learn of any documented case of an
Addisonian crisis where the patient has recovered and gone on
to live a normal life without the necessary medical
treatment. I don't believe such a thing exists.
However, if Dr. Bhatia really does have such cases (the "I'm
sure" doesn't sound all that sure to me), perhaps he'd care to
come here and post some details? This would be a medical
first. If confirmed, it would turn everyone's ideas
about endocrinology on their heads. Indeed, it would
turn most of known physics and chemistry on their heads.
Rolfe.
Edited for lousy spelling.
Edited by Rolfie on 04 July 04
at 17:32 |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Rolfie Newbie

Joined:
04 July 04 Location: England Online Status:
Offline Posts: 9 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 17:29 | IP Logged |
|
|
Hello, Exarch. You're up late too. Well, I have
sick animals to see to tomorrow morning, so I really must go
to bed.
Interestingly enough, although it was my weekend off, I got
a worried call from my on-duty colleague on Saturday
morning. A dog with a possible/probable case of
Addison's, believe it or not. (Except that it's not that
uncommon a condition, and in very hot or very cold weather we
often see more than one a week.) What to do? Well,
we got it sorted out all right.
We deal all the time with geniune illness which won't get
better unless genuine medicine is applied. Attitudes
like "By the time they get here, they've already been
poisoned, mutilated, and relieved of their life savings.
Nonetheless, they believe they've taken the right steps in
seeing the "real" doctors first. If only they knew that the
modern medical paradigm is built on a faulty premise!" don't
exactly annoy me, this is hardly a flea-bite in the huge
pile of trouble needing fixed that I encounter every
day. But every time I encounter an animal suffering or
dying because somebody believed it, I get really upset.
And it happens.
Goodnight all.
Morituri te salutamus.
Rolfe.
|
| Back to Top |
|
| |
Snoopy Silver Member


Joined: 06 April 03
Online Status: Online Posts: 2156 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 17:45 | IP Logged |
|
|
Did someone say
that people would die if all they got was shaken
water? Why would we give empty water to people that were
dying? Why would we be devoting our lives to studying
water? Don't you think that after the 10th or 20th time
we gave Arnica to injured people and nothing happened that
we'd tire of the embarrassment? How many people in ill
health are going to favor us with the placebo response?
Your premise that we give water to sick people and they get
well just please us despite being perfect strangers who
couldn't care less who we are is
ridiculous.
Snoopy
Edited by Snoopy on 04 July 04
at 17:46 |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
exarch Newbie

Joined:
31 May 04 Online Status: Online Posts: 3 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 17:47 | IP Logged |
|
|
Rolfie wrote:
|
But every time I encounter an animal
suffering or dying because somebody believed it,
I get really upset. And it
happens. | | |
Well, we've had this line of discussion before, about how
someone apparently has to die before homeopaths will recognise
their remedies aren't working, only to then backtrack and
claim it wasn't the fact that their remedies didn't work, but
the evil allopathic doctors who screwed it up beyond repair
before they could get to it that are to blame for the death. I
take comfort in knowing that some day the whole thing will be
recognised, by the law and the court, for the quackery it
really is, and people will go to jail for dispensing bunk
medical advice without being trained medical professionals
(and that means real doctors, not know-it-all
nurses surreptitiously working behind the back of real
doctors). |
| Back to Top |
|
| |
exarch Newbie

Joined:
31 May 04 Online Status: Online Posts: 3 |
| Posted:
04 July 04 at 17:56 | IP Logged |
|
|
Snoopy wrote:
| Did someone say
that people would die if all they got
was shaken water? Why would we give empty
water to people that were dying? Why would
we be devoting our lives to studying
water? Don't you think that after the 10th
or 20th time we gave Arnica to injured people
and nothing happened that we'd tire of the
embarrassment? | | |
No, I believe the standard procedure is to
retake the case after a couple of failures and switch to
another kind of shaken water, until a patient either gets
better on their own, or worse (aggravation), or nothing
happens and you repeat the process.
Further more, homeopathy seems to be very
efficient in dealing with chronic ailments that often go in
remission on their own, or get better every now and again
anyway (hence, "chronic", i.e. with
intervals). People with chronic ailments are the ones
desperate for a cure, which their regular doctor often can't
provide them with (hey, surprise, real doctors don't lie to
their patients, and will tell them that whatever treatment
they are giving could be a long shot and may not work at
all).
People with simple ailments like sprained
ankles and other physical injuries don't go to the homeopath,
which works in your favor, since healing those leaves very
little wiggle room for placebo effect.
Quote:
| How many people in
ill health are going to favor us with the
placebo response? Your premise that we
give water to sick people and they get well just
please us despite being perfect strangers who
couldn't care less who we are is
ridiculous. | | |
Placebo effect is a kind of preprogrammed response of
feeling better when being taken care of and handed some
pills by a doctor-like person. It matters little whether that
doctor-like person is a stranger or not. |
| Back to Top |
|
| | | |