Active TopicsActive Topics  Search The ForumSearch  HelpHelp
  RegisterRegister  LoginLogin
Chit-Chat
 Hpathy Forums : Chit-Chat
Subject Topic: A Case from Rolfe who needs help? Post ReplyPost New Topic
Author
Message << Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Snoopy
Silver Member
Silver Member
Avatar

Joined: 06 April 03
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 2164
Posted: 04 July 04 at 18:03 | IP Logged Quote Snoopy

Dear Exarche,

I understand your concern.  You want people to be safe; I want the same thing.  You are appalled at "alternative methods" that prevent people from getting proper medical care.  I can understand where you're coming from, I've been on your side myself. 

Homeopathy was begun by a medical doctor 200 years ago, it's older than the medicine you practice now.  You can't lump it in with other alternative therapies, it predates many of them.  Acupuncture used to be laughed at but no one's laughing any more.  Acupuncture is based on the premise that there are energy pathways in the body that can't be seen but can be the source of illness if the energy is blocked.  Homeopathy similarly postulates that there is an "energy body" which can be affected by "energetic medicine."  My hope is that someday you'll be willing to look into this concept; there's really no point in either of us clashing swords any further.

Sorry you dislike my bright colors.

Snoopy



__________________
Diploma, Hahnemann Academy of North America
Back to Top View Snoopy's Profile Search for other posts by Snoopy
 
Rolfie
Newbie
Newbie


Joined: 04 July 04
Location: England
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 11
Posted: 04 July 04 at 18:19 | IP Logged Quote Rolfie

Well, about the bright colours, that was me.  It was more wondering why you did it, but I've come to expect not getting an answer to a straight question from a homoeopath.

I can't see any point in getting into all this about energy bodies and the elusive memory of water/sugar pills or whatever.  Except to say that the metabolic pathways of energy in the body are very well understood, and nobody has ever succeeded in measuring anything even remotely like what you describe.  And there are very many people either laughing at acupuncture too, or more likely tearing their hair out that yet another old chestnut is making a reappearance.

I've studied this more than you perhaps realise.  If you paddle in the shallows of medicine, which is where you're operating I'm afraid, it's remarkably easy to be misled by a combination of wishful thinking and coincidental recovery into becoming convinced that content-free remedies are having some beneficial effect.  Add to that the homoeopathic system of having an explanation for whatever happens (aggravations that aren't adverse reactions and so on), and it's perhaps not surprising.

Well, I'm fairly interested in the conversion from

"By the time they get here, they've already been poisoned, mutilated, and relieved of their life savings. Nonetheless, they believe they've taken the right steps in seeing the "real" doctors first. If only they knew that the modern medical paradigm is built on a faulty premise!"

to

"I think this is a good example to everyone of what can happen if we fail to get a proper diagnosis and begin treating on symptoms alone--a big mistake, as shown here."

If this has done anything at all to make homoeopaths think twice about their central credo of eschewing "allopathic" diagnosis and treating on symptoms alone (excuse me, I thought that was one of the core platforms homoeopathy was based on, but I'm glad to learn better), then something has perhaps been achieved.

Rolfe.

 

Back to Top View Rolfie's Profile Search for other posts by Rolfie
 
exarch
Newbie
Newbie


Joined: 31 May 04
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 9
Posted: 04 July 04 at 18:23 | IP Logged Quote exarch

I am not simply appaled at alternative methods because they deny people proper medical care, but because they also claim to be many things they are not, ranging from being a cure all remedy, to a tried and tested method. Neither of which are true for homeopathy.

And accupuncture, despite being one of the few alternative methods to date that actually has an actual physical interaction with the body (which cannot be found with homeopathy or crystal-healing or laying on hands, or whatever floats your boat), is still not proven to work. And if it could be proven to do something, anything, I'm sure it's not going to be because of some mystical, undetectable energy, but because the needles are physically interacting with the body, or even stimulating nerves or hormone production.

So I'm afraid your "energetic medicine" has no further ties with reality than voodoo or any other kind of healing magic.
So until anyone can show scientificly valid evidence that anything beyond placebo is happening, I don't see why we wouldn't be better off investing money in advancing real medicine, so quackery like homeopathy is no longer needed anyway.



Edited by exarch on 04 July 04 at 18:26
Back to Top View exarch's Profile Search for other posts by exarch
 
exarch
Newbie
Newbie


Joined: 31 May 04
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 9
Posted: 04 July 04 at 18:34 | IP Logged Quote exarch

Snoopy wrote:
Homeopathy was begun by a medical doctor 200 years ago, it's older than the medicine you practice now.

I just thought I'd point out this glaring error in reasoning:
Being older doesn't mean better.
In fact, I'd rather drive a brand new modern Mercedes than an old banged up 1950's VW Beetle without power steering, Anti locking brakes, seat belts, airbags, crumple zones, and the latest all weather tires. I'll admit it's a more expensive car, but it's so much more technologically advanced and, obviously: SAFER!!

But hey, older is better, right?



Edited by exarch on 04 July 04 at 18:38
Back to Top View exarch's Profile Search for other posts by exarch
 
Snoopy
Silver Member
Silver Member
Avatar

Joined: 06 April 03
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 2164
Posted: 04 July 04 at 19:18 | IP Logged Quote Snoopy

Rolfe,

I can't answer everything that's thrown at me, but i'll try to respond to this:

"Well, I'm fairly interested in the conversion from

'By the time they get here, they've already been poisoned, mutilated, and relieved of their life savings. Nonetheless, they believe they've taken the right steps in seeing the "real" doctors first. If only they knew that the modern medical paradigm is built on a faulty premise!'

to

'I think this is a good example to everyone of what can happen if we fail to get a proper diagnosis and begin treating on symptoms alone--a big mistake, as shown here.'"

Rolfe, a diagnosis isn't the same thing as a treatment plan.  Diagnosis is good!  It's important.  It's one of the areas where modern medicine shines.  We can find out, for instance, if a person has Addison's disease or food poisoning!  The treatment for one would be entirely different that the treatment for the other.  So, we must have a diagnosis.  But, now, this is an interesting illustrative subject, because "you guys", in a case of food poisoning, would give an anti-emetic, and some sort of opiate to stop the diarrhea. 

The homeopaths, on the other hand would say, "The symptoms aren't the disease, the symptoms are our immune system's response, trying to eliminate the disease."  Homeopathic remedies are in "agreement" with the immune system, in that in substance form, they would cause, or agree with, what the immune system is doing. 

Hahnemann observed that when two similar diseases came together in the body, they cancelled each other out.  The phenomenon of similars repelling is well known.  Our remedies are artificial diseases, not medicine per se.  They are meant to replicated the phenomenon observed by Hahnemann. 

You think the dilutions (remedies) are empty.  Yes they are empty of substance but not of energetics.

I'm sorry to hear you base your whole opposition to homeopathy on placebo.  It's so thin, Rolfe.  We give remedies and nothing happens.  We keep trying.  Finally something works.  Why didn't it work with the first one?  There's less likely to be a placebo response after the person has been disappointed repeatedly.  If the sick individual is disposed to respond favorably to a healer, it would happen immediately and not after hours have gone by.  Even just last night, my friend Kppy had a fever following dental work--drilling into the jaw bone.  I said, "Take Arnica, it must be Arnica!"  How long did she take Arnica, for at least a day; nothing happened despite repeated doses.  I couldn't believe it.  I said, "Well, you don't have Calendula, you don't have Pyrogen which are the usual ones to try for this...try Hepar sulph."  She emailed me a short time later:  fever gone!  Why didn't it stop with the Arnica?  I believed in Arnica, she believed in Arnica!  So, you see, the placebo idea, Rolfe, I can simply shoot holes in it.  People are very irritable when they're sick, they're in no mood to be concerned with your or anyone else's feelings.  Yes, they can be calmed by another person's caring and presence, it helps, I would never deny it, but if it were sufficient, no one would ever need to see the doctor, because they'd all get well by virtue of Mom holding their hand and Dad bringing them tea.  It's just not enough.

Snoopy

Back to Top View Snoopy's Profile Search for other posts by Snoopy
 
Barb
Silver Member
Silver Member
Avatar

Joined: 11 Aug. 03
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 398
Posted: 04 July 04 at 19:42 | IP Logged Quote Barb

Snoopy - you of all people would think "older is better"

Listen - this isn't a friendly discussion - Rolfe has just put in HER sig line at randiland the quote you gave about this being a good lesson to get a diagnosis and then states the quote is from Snoopy at Hpathy "who just allowed a mother with addisons disease to die".  No mention that it is a fake case - that you never saw a person, took a case or perscribed anything and that NH gave the case as a fake one from Rolfe from the beginning.  I thought you would be interested in the liable she is spreading about you since it concerns you killing a young mother. 

I have always loved her other signature line "that's the thing about medicine, it's all about the numbers" - Very fitting isn't it?  I would say "that's the thing about homeopathy, it's all about the patients".

Back to Top View Barb's Profile Search for other posts by Barb
 
Barb
Silver Member
Silver Member
Avatar

Joined: 11 Aug. 03
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 398
Posted: 04 July 04 at 19:52 | IP Logged Quote Barb

exarche,

 

Yep, modern medicine is always changing always "growing" but then that means the treatment youhad yesterday wasn't the "best or safest" and the treatemnt you had last week really wasn't the "best and safest" and the one you had last year was surely bad and dangerous compared to today - go back to 200 hundred years ago where "modern medicine" was barbaric - if we lived back then you would be extolling the virtues of leeches and lancing and cupping and purging - all barbaric treatments by todays standards but because it was what modern medicine used you would be saying it was the correct treatment.  There is somehting to be said for a treamtnt that doesn't change becasue it doesn't need to change.  After all, human beings haven't changed much in 200 years, our physiology hasn't been altered, what worked then works now.

ANd by the way - if you can get off your soapbox can you actually show me just one case where homeopathy (actual homeopathy, not herbal medicine or psychic medicine or anyother alternative medicine) killed someone?)  Just one case - where a classically trained and classically practicing homeopath took the case and did somehting to kill the client - you guys rant about this all the time so somewhere it must be very common.

Back to Top View Barb's Profile Search for other posts by Barb
 
Snoopy
Silver Member
Silver Member
Avatar

Joined: 06 April 03
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 2164
Posted: 04 July 04 at 19:59 | IP Logged Quote Snoopy

Rolfe,

Tell me she's kidding!  You wrote that as a fact, with no explanation so that people will actually believe that it actually happened?  That's reprehensible Rolfe; I'm the one who said that you reminded us of the importance of having a diagnosis and you go and...why do we even talk to you?  Do you see what kind of people you are?  Has anyone here slandered you here at hpathy, Rolfe?  Has anyone here lied about you?  I would appreciate it if you removed my name from your posts at Randiland; you are truly dispicable; i really had you pegged wrong!

Snoopy



Edited by Snoopy on 04 July 04 at 20:24
Back to Top View Snoopy's Profile Search for other posts by Snoopy
 
Homeopath Syed
Senior Member
Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 20 April 04
Location: Pakistan
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 136
Posted: 04 July 04 at 22:34 | IP Logged Quote Homeopath Syed

OK Rolfe,

Now its was text-book case... Would you please mention what "PILL" was she on ? and from how long ? Have you really listed down the side affects of that PILL. Have you considered that drugging may produce symptoms lik Addisons Disease. WHAT WOULD YOU HAVE GIVEN HER FOR IT BASED ON THE TEXT YOU WROTE ? CLINICALLY SPEAKING PLEASE... The craving for salt is predominently a Tubercular diathesis. The change in Color of Skin strenthen it too. Yes the patient would NOT have died...unless treated by your medicines.

You say we can't cure Addison's Disease .. leave aside our answer to it... because its not an evidence that "Others" are equally flabberghasted by it.

How easy was it for you to word Hydrocortisones.... We make sure our patents doesn't get one .. and they heal either way and better and faster.

You want somehing that works.. your way only... Next time you meet a patient of SARS... give him Senega-30 3 hourly for 2 days. The difference between Steriods and Homeopathywould dawn on you soon.

<Sorry Guys... I mention specific...I had to.. I am not dealing a patient here. Its the text-book cases man who needs to meet a real patient yet>.

 



__________________
Homeopath Dr. F.A.Syed
Islamabad, Pakistan
Back to Top View Homeopath Syed's Profile Search for other posts by Homeopath Syed Visit Homeopath Syed's Homepage
 
PacificParent
Newbie
Newbie


Joined: 04 July 04
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 1
Posted: 04 July 04 at 23:11 | IP Logged Quote PacificParent

Some notes...

 

1)  There seem to be no homeopathic hospitals left in the United States.  If there are, please correct me.

 

2) Snoopy, since you are in a public ezine... and your actual name was only used ONCE in Randiland in any other way than a link to articles you wrote... then you have no complaint.

 

3)  The FDA only permits the selling for homoepathic remedies for conditions that are self limiting.  Look up for yourself... they are starting to go after people who do not comply --- so if I were you I would be careful about how you practice your "medicine" (see http://www.homeowatch.org/reg/gray.html )

 

4)  Real people have died when they have relied on homeopathy... the most recent was an epileptic toddler in Australia:

http://www.theage.com.au/articles/2003/11/26/1069825838204.html?from=storyrhs&oneclick=true

Some more:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=15030747

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=14143194

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=14147765

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=3624689

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=pubmed&dopt=Abstract&list_uids=11450589

 

Good night... And I am saving this thread on my hard drive

Back to Top View PacificParent's Profile Search for other posts by PacificParent
 
Homeopath Syed
Senior Member
Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 20 April 04
Location: Pakistan
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 136
Posted: 04 July 04 at 23:58 | IP Logged Quote Homeopath Syed

Pacific Parent,

While Snoopy reply to you ... I budge in.

Its good have you here...

I went to all of the links you mentioned above and really couldn't find the evidence against homeopahs. Grey is marketting his product against the laws, So he has to be treated accordingly.

Would you like to know of deaths caused by Allopathic Treatment her in the public. I ll give you details from 1900 century to the Tetracyclene and to AZTs of today.

Go to the link and find out what many related experts say about it.

http://www.virusmyth.net/aids/

I would really like to know WHY PEOPLE DEVELOPED "CORTICOPHOBIA" in the first place?

They think they give them life by taking off their bone-density.

People do turn to homeopathy for asthmas...Why ?

What we face here in Islamabad is again an epidemic Asthma is more of complications due to Steriods. Anyone who comes to us first never develops the grave situations of the disease.


Thanks for reading



__________________
Homeopath Dr. F.A.Syed
Islamabad, Pakistan
Back to Top View Homeopath Syed's Profile Search for other posts by Homeopath Syed Visit Homeopath Syed's Homepage
 
Homeopath Syed
Senior Member
Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 20 April 04
Location: Pakistan
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 136
Posted: 05 July 04 at 00:44 | IP Logged Quote Homeopath Syed

WANT TO KNOW WHO KILLS ?

1-

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=retrieve&db=pubmed&list_uids=2270944&dopt=abstract

2-

http://www.lef.org/magazine/mag2004/mar2004_awsi_death_01.htm

"The most stunning statistic, however, is that the total number of deaths caused by conventional medicine is an astounding 783,936 per year. It is now evident that the American medical system is the leading cause of death and injury in the US. (By contrast, the number of deaths attributable to heart disease in 2001 was 699,697, while the number of deaths attributable to cancer was 553,251.5) .."

3-

http://www.annieappleseedproject.org/deatinermed.html

Each year in the United States:

12,000 people die from unnecessary surgery;

7,000 people die from medication errors in hospitals;

20,000 people die from other hospital error;

80,000 die from infections contracted in hospitals;

106,000 deaths from properly prescribed pharmaceutical drugs.

In other words, an estimated 225,000 deaths are caused by U.S. health-care system annually.

Source: These figures come from Dr. Barbara Starfield, of the Johns Hopkins School of Hygiene and Public Health, and were recently published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA).

4-

http://www.mercola.com/2002/jan/2/medical_errors.htm

Deaths in England Due to Medical Errors up 500%

 

By Sarah Lyall

About 1,200 people died in public hospitals in Britain last year because of mistakes in prescribing and administering medicine, according to a report published by a government watchdog group.

You want more here...?

AND YOUR QUESTION ABOUT HOMEOPATHY IN US.

Read here...if you like to know..Its on the Rise...

http://www.homeopathic.com/articles/intro/international_h.php

 

PS.. I am saving this thread on my HD too...

 



Edited by Homeopath Syed on 05 July 04 at 00:58


__________________
Homeopath Dr. F.A.Syed
Islamabad, Pakistan
Back to Top View Homeopath Syed's Profile Search for other posts by Homeopath Syed Visit Homeopath Syed's Homepage
 
Rolfie
Newbie
Newbie


Joined: 04 July 04
Location: England
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 11
Posted: 05 July 04 at 02:56 | IP Logged Quote Rolfie

Good morning!  I'm quite surprised to be still alive here, given the innocuous comments I've seen people banned for in the past, but there you go!

I'm aware you're not very happy with the way this thread has gone.  I'd just remind you that I didn't start it, and you really ought to consider the role of Naturalhealth in what has been going on.  It wasn't my decision to post here what was always intended to be a hypothetical case.  If you'd like a look at her triumphalist post on the matter, see http://www.randi.org/vbulletin/showthread.php?s=&threadid=42759.  (Her "Corallinus" identity has since been banned there, simply because she was posting under two identities, which is explicitly forbidden in that forum.  Her other identity, "Homeoskeptic" is currently under a week's suspension, but I assume she'll be back.)

And if you want to see the original context of the Addison's disease challenge to Kumar, it starts about here.  http://www.randi.org/vbulletin/showthread.php?s=&postid=1870522061#post1870522061  Note that there was no attempt to conceal the "trap".  Naturalhealth simply didn't notice, and copied what was in fact the third repetition (as Kumar is extremely difficult to get an answer out of), where it wasn't so obvious.

Snoopy, yes, I have that comment about the Addison's case in my sig line at JREF.  If you actually look, you'll see that the citation includes a link to this thread, so anyone who is at all interested can come here and see quite clearly that the case was hypothetical.  And since your real name is presumably not "Snoopy", I'm not really clear that any person is being unjustly maligned.

You asserted that "So, we must have a diagnosis.  But, now, this is an interesting illustrative subject, because "you guys", in a case of food poisoning, would give an anti-emetic, and some sort of opiate to stop the diarrhea."

Well, can I emphasise once more the astounding U-turn in this matter of the diagnosis.  Do you really insist that you can't and won't treat a patient until they have an "allopathic" diagnosis?  Is all this talk about seeing a homoeopath first entirely wrong, and homoeopaths in fact will only see patients who have already been seen by a real doctor?  Surely you don't believe that homoeopathy training and a homoeopath's consulting room, lacking in any diagnostic aids, is sufficient resource to be certain of a diagnosis which may take a well-equipped hospital much investigation with blood test, x-rays, ultrasound and so on?  Can we really rest assured that homoeopaths are all taught to refer to a doctor for diagnosis before they take a case?  If so, I'm extremely relieved to hear it.

I must also tell you that piling in to food-poisoning cases with anti-emetics and opiates is far from my general practice.  Bland high-fibre diet and probiotics is much more my style.  However, once again I have to explain to a homoeopath that treatment is individualised, and there might be cases where the presenting signs do require more "heroic" intervention.

As usual, we seem to be back to the homoeopaths dredging up everything they can find about real medicine having adverse effects.

First, I'd like to point out that at least in real medicine it's mandatory to record such occurrences through proper channels.  That's why you can find them so easily.  We simply have no way of knowing the incidence of severe "aggravations", and cases which went wrong and so on with homoeopathy, because the entire discipline is unaccountable, unregulated and unscrutinised.  There simply are no central records where we can look such things up.

And then we're back to the metaphor of the feather and the chain-saw.  Real medicine is like someone trying to cut down a tree with a chain saw.  Accidents happen.  "No," says the homoeoapth, "that's much too dangerous.  Here, use this nice safe feather."  We're not disputing that feathers cause less accidents than chain saws.  However, are they effective for the job in hand? Is there not a good argument for simply trying to improve the safety of the chain saw, and use it as prudently as possible?

(This of course presupposes the claim that as homoeopathic remedies are content-free, so how can they be harmful?  Indeed.  But if we then say, homoeopathic remedies are content-free, so how can they do any good, this is hotly disputed.  Perhaps another day we might address the paradox of claiming that something has a biological effect, but that this effect must always and only be for the good.  While at the same time reporting many instances of very unpleasant "aggravations" and so on that are never considered or collated as adverse reactions.)

And finally, this one again.  "You think the dilutions (remedies) are empty.  Yes they are empty of substance but not of energetics."

Now you know and I know and every practising homoeopath knows and any homoeopathic "pharmacist" knows that there is simply no way at all to distinguish a homoeopathically-prepared "high-potency" remedy from the chemically-identical stock solvent.  Not in vitro, not in vivo, no way.  Not by any analysis method known to mankind, or dowsing, or Vega-testing, or anything.  Neither is it possible by looking for "proving" effects, or by observing to see if there is any difference between patients given their remedy and patients who only thought they'd been given their remedy.  It's simply never been done.  Face it, with the JREF million dollars available for doing it, and the enormous degree of legitimacy that such a demonstration would confer on homoeopathy, if it were possible at all, some homoeopath, somewhere, would have done it by now.

So really, I don't see why it's so unthinkable to refer to your stock-in-trade as "content-free".  These alleged dramatic effects and miracle cures simply disappear to the borders of statistical significance whenever a controlled trial is undertaken.  Nobody can find, measure or characterise these mysterious "energies".  Is it any wonder that many people are a mite sceptical?

The simple points I was trying to emphasise in the first place remain.

First, are homoeopaths diagnostically skilled enough to be relied on to recognise a possible case of a life-threatening condition where the consequences of not treating with real medicine very quickly might be tragic?  I have to say I'm still not convinced.

Second, do homoeopaths recognise that there are conditions where real treatment with real medicine with real molecules in it is essential?  Obviously some do, but comments like "If only they knew that the modern medical paradigm is built on a faulty premise!" and the various remarks about "allopathic" medicine being pure poison (and none of these remarks ever seems to be deleted or banned) don't really instill a lot of confidence.

However, if we have agreed that homoeopaths ought to have a propeer medical diagnosis before they take a case, and that they mustn't try to handle life-threatening conditions where real medicine is needed, then I feel this thread has certainly achieved something.

Rolfe.

 

Back to Top View Rolfie's Profile Search for other posts by Rolfie
 
exarch
Newbie
Newbie


Joined: 31 May 04
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 9
Posted: 05 July 04 at 03:33 | IP Logged Quote exarch

Homeopath Syed wrote:
http://www.lef.org/magazine/mag2004/mar2004_awsi_death_01.ht%20m

"The most stunning statistic, however, is that the total number of deaths caused by conventional medicine is an astounding 783,936 per year. It is now evident that the American medical system is the leading cause of death and injury in the US. (By contrast, the number of deaths attributable to heart disease in 2001 was 699,697, while the number of deaths attributable to cancer was 553,251.5) .."

It continues:
Quote:
We placed this article on our website to memorialize the failure of the American medical system. By exposing these gruesome statistics in painstaking detail, we provide a basis for competent and compassionate medical professionals to recognize the inadequacies of today’s system and at least attempt to institute meaningful reforms.
So obviously, conventional medicine is not what's being blamed here directly, but the American medical system.

Also, people in hospital are more likely to die than others because, DUH!!, they're in hospital for a reason you know, and that is problems with their health. It also doesn't say whether they died in hospital after having received homeopathic remedies and not getting better. It just says they died.

Homeopath Syed wrote:
12,000 people die from unnecessary surgery;

Does "plastic surgery" mean anything to you? It's unnecessary, but you choose to have it voluntarily.

Homeopath Syed wrote:
7,000 people die from medication errors in hospitals;

20,000 people die from other hospital error;

80,000 die from infections contracted in hospitals;

So you wouldn't happen to know how many died after using homeopathy, would you? In fact, you don't even know how many got better using only homeopathy, or how many tried conventional medicine and switched to homeopathy, or vice-versa. You have no statistics whatsoever, and the numbers might be worse, we just don't know ...

Homeopath Syed wrote:
106,000 deaths from properly prescribed pharmaceutical drugs.

Just like you homeopaths to screw up cause and effect again. People took homeopathy, they got better, it was the homeopathy. People took conventional medication, they died, it was the conventional medication.

But was it?



Edited by exarch on 05 July 04 at 03:34
Back to Top View exarch's Profile Search for other posts by exarch
 
exarch
Newbie
Newbie


Joined: 31 May 04
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 9
Posted: 05 July 04 at 03:51 | IP Logged Quote exarch

Barb wrote:
Yep, modern medicine is always changing always "growing" but then that means the treatment youhad yesterday wasn't the "best or safest" and the treatemnt you had last week really wasn't the "best and safest" and the one you had last year was surely bad and dangerous compared to today - go back to 200 hundred years ago where "modern medicine" was barbaric - if we lived back then you would be extolling the virtues of leeches and lancing and cupping and purging - all barbaric treatments by todays standards but because it was what modern medicine used you would be saying it was the correct treatment.  There is somehting to be said for a treamtnt that doesn't change becasue it doesn't need to change.  After all, human beings haven't changed much in 200 years, our physiology hasn't been altered, what worked then works now.

You're completely right Barb, the placebo effect hasn't changed since it was first discovered by witchdoctors in the stone age, but I tend to prefer a more 21st century kind of medicine if you don't mind. And yes, the treatment I got last year was not as advanced as the one they're dispensing now, and removing an inflamed appendix now only leaves a scar the size of housefly, where it used to be a scar across half your belly. That doesn't mean that the procedure used to be bad, it's just been perfected, and made safer.

Homeopathy on the other hand doesn't evolve, it doesn't need to evolve, it doesn't do anything to begin with really, so there's nothing to improve anyway.

Barb, I think what most homeopaths still fail to see is that if there are such extraordinary claims and miracle cures, it should be possible to at least prove something's happening. There's a million dollars sitting there, unclaimed, waiting for a homeopath to show homeopathy has a detectable effect, any effect, anything at all. So far, nobody has managed to take it. Not even close ...

The logical conclusion to make is that the homeopathic remedies don't do anything, and there are other factors at work here. I think it would be much more interesting to find out in detail what those factors really are, instead of wasting time and money on empty remedies and concocting wacky theories about energies and the thus far non-existent water-memory.



Edited by exarch on 05 July 04 at 03:52
Back to Top View exarch's Profile Search for other posts by exarch
 
Barb
Silver Member
Silver Member
Avatar

Joined: 11 Aug. 03
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 398
Posted: 05 July 04 at 06:39 | IP Logged Quote Barb

pacific parten

the first case cited the patient was NOT I repeat NOT treated by a homeopath - for all the rest, how do you access the actual articles?

Back to Top View Barb's Profile Search for other posts by Barb
 
Barb
Silver Member
Silver Member
Avatar

Joined: 11 Aug. 03
Location: United States
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 398
Posted: 05 July 04 at 06:49 | IP Logged Quote Barb

Snoopy - here is Rolfes sig line

"To give Rolfe his due, I think this is a good example to everyone of what can happen if we fail to get a proper diagnosis and begin treating on symptoms alone--a big mistake, as shown here."
- "Snoopy" on
H'pathy Forums, apparently abjuring the very fundamentals of homoeopathy after she'd just allowed a young mother with Addison's disease to die.

emphasis mine.

Back to Top View Barb's Profile Search for other posts by Barb
 
Homeopath Syed
Senior Member
Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 20 April 04
Location: Pakistan
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 136
Posted: 05 July 04 at 07:10 | IP Logged Quote Homeopath Syed

Negative Barb,

Go to the first two posts. It was me who asked the patient to narrate the SIDE AFFECTS of the Pill she was on. Hypothetically as it turned out. The virtual patient has not done so. That was the first step towards TREATMENT, that would have followed.

Is there any other questions that any good doc would have asked to begin with. If yes, I would really think of him as a magician than a doctor.

Suppose the PILL doesn't had those side affects listed... Ofcourse she would have got the remedy in 20 mins and be on path of cure. But suppose that PILL had the side affects listed as the original symptoms. Giving any medicine without countering it, could have caused serious trouble to the patient that these people usually do. <See my post above>. Snoopy has rightfully, logically and rationally asked the similar question.

Upon asking one question Rolfe expolded..."your patient is dead, your patien is dead.".... OH REALLY....???

I have here with me and I can arrange them to talk to you, a female patient who was prescribed a PILL. She developed loss of sight esp waking up in morning and called the Gyno back, Gyno said "No its not because of the PILL. Then she came to me with the PRINT OUT of the medicine, No mention of any side affect on vision. Her husband then searched the net and He found it written in RED that the medicine may cause temporary blurring of vision in few cases.

..and all of you suddenly start teaching us that we do not go look for the SIDE AFFECTS of a MEDICINE that is in use by the Patient ?

NOW YOU ANSWER IT RIGHT BEFORE YOU PROCEED FORWARD.

 



__________________
Homeopath Dr. F.A.Syed
Islamabad, Pakistan
Back to Top View Homeopath Syed's Profile Search for other posts by Homeopath Syed Visit Homeopath Syed's Homepage
 
Homeopath Syed
Senior Member
Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 20 April 04
Location: Pakistan
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 136
Posted: 05 July 04 at 07:12 | IP Logged Quote Homeopath Syed

And for the Placebo Effect...!

I had already mentioned "Croton Tig -30" THE PLACEBO for those who wants to prove its palcebo. A dose for 5 straight days ... Try Natrum Mur-30 BD for 2 days...

You say its placebo... You take it.. We say its medicine and we use it to heal our patients.

Whats the big deal about it writing and writing ..Its a PLB... Its A PLB...Why not finish it by proving it on yourself...

AND THEN...

Did you ever thought why its the Homeopaths that give you all the trouble to write and fight. Not the Herbalists, Not the Acupuncutists, Pressure therapists, Chinese Medicine, Not even Ayurvaedics, Not even Hypnotists, Neither the Radionic therapists.....Not even wizard healers..

ONLY THE HOMEOPATHS PINCH THEM SOMEWHERE.

YES Its we who you FEAR.

 



Edited by Homeopath Syed on 05 July 04 at 07:25


__________________
Homeopath Dr. F.A.Syed
Islamabad, Pakistan
Back to Top View Homeopath Syed's Profile Search for other posts by Homeopath Syed Visit Homeopath Syed's Homepage
 
Homeopath Syed
Senior Member
Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 20 April 04
Location: Pakistan
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 136
Posted: 05 July 04 at 08:21 | IP Logged Quote Homeopath Syed

Lastly for the need of Allopathic Diagnosis...

NO WE DO NOT NEED ONE TO TREAT OUR PATIENTS....

We rely on Objective and Subjective symptoms together or apart.

Anyone homeopath who thinks  he needs an Allopathic Diagnosis to treat a PATIENT.. may please.. post here again.

 

 



__________________
Homeopath Dr. F.A.Syed
Islamabad, Pakistan
Back to Top View Homeopath Syed's Profile Search for other posts by Homeopath Syed Visit Homeopath Syed's Homepage
 
Homeopath Syed
Senior Member
Senior Member
Avatar

Joined: 20 April 04
Location: Pakistan
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 136
Posted: 05 July 04 at 08:22 | IP Logged Quote Homeopath Syed

Lastly for the need of Allopathic Diagnosis...

NO WE DO NOT NEED ONE TO TREAT OUR PATIENTS....

We rely on Objective and Subjective symptoms together or apart.

Anyone homeopath who thinks  he needs an Allopathic Diagnosis to treat a PATIENT.. may please.. post here again.



__________________
Homeopath Dr. F.A.Syed
Islamabad, Pakistan
Back to Top View Homeopath Syed's Profile Search for other posts by Homeopath Syed Visit Homeopath Syed's Homepage
 
exarch
Newbie
Newbie


Joined: 31 May 04
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 9
Posted: 05 July 04 at 09:01 | IP Logged Quote exarch

Homeopath Syed wrote:
Did you ever thought why its the Homeopaths that give you all the trouble to write and fight. Not the Herbalists, Not the Acupuncutists, Pressure therapists, Chinese Medicine, Not even Ayurvaedics, Not even Hypnotists, Neither the Radionic therapists.....Not even wizard healers..

ONLY THE HOMEOPATHS PINCH THEM SOMEWHERE.

YES Its we who you FEAR.

Actually, all of them are quacks, but the homeopaths are the ones currently scamming the most people out of their hard owned cash.

So a question to you Syed:
Which of the other quackeries you listed above do you NOT believe in, and if so, why not?



Edited by exarch on 05 July 04 at 09:02
Back to Top View exarch's Profile Search for other posts by exarch
 
Snoopy
Silver Member
Silver Member
Avatar

Joined: 06 April 03
Online Status: Offline
Posts: 2164
Posted: 05 July 04 at 09:12 | IP Logged Quote Snoopy

Rolfe,

you're a g.d. s.o.b.!  You change that dispicable signature line; there's no excuse for it--this is why you people are banned from here, not because we dislike discourse, on the contrary; what we dislike are frat boys where every day's another day of hazing!

Snoopy

Back to Top View Snoopy's Profile Search for other posts by Snoopy
 
The RealMonkey
Newbie
Newbie


Joined: 27 June 04
Online Status: Online
Posts: 10
Posted: 05 July 04 at 09:15 | IP Logged Quote The RealMonkey

Homeopath Syed wrote:


Suppose the PILL doesn't had those side
affects listed... Ofcourse she would have got the remedy in 20 mins
and be on path of cure.




So Syed is staking a claim that he would have treated this
dangerously ill patient with homeopathy alone once he had ruled out
by his own judgement the Pill causing the reported symptoms.

Noted.
Back to Top View The RealMonkey's Profile Search for other posts by The RealMonkey
 
The RealMonkey
Newbie
Newbie


Joined: 27 June 04
Online Status: Online
Posts: 10
Posted: 05 July 04 at 09:17 | IP Logged Quote The RealMonkey

Snoopy wrote:


But, now, this is an interesting illustrative subject, because "you
guys", in a case of food poisoning, would give an anti-emetic, and
some sort of opiate to stop the diarrhea. 



You need to stop visiting Dr Strawman for your first line advice on
medicine!
Back to Top View The RealMonkey's Profile Search for other posts by The RealMonkey
 

<< Prev Page of 3 Next >>
  Post ReplyPost New Topic
Printable version Printable version

Forum Jump
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot create polls in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum